#H (elim H) /2/ normalize #c #d #H1 #H2 #H3 @(trans_star … H3) /2/
qed.
+lemma star_decomp_l :
+ ∀A,R,x,y.star A R x y → x = y ∨ ∃z.R x z ∧ star A R z y.
+#A #R #x #y #Hstar elim Hstar
+[ #b #c #Hleft #Hright *
+ [ #H1 %2 @(ex_intro ?? c) % //
+ | * #x0 * #H1 #H2 %2 @(ex_intro ?? x0) % /2/ ]
+| /2/ ]
+qed.
+
+(* right associative version of star *)
+inductive starl (A:Type[0]) (R:relation A) : A → A → Prop ≝
+ |injl: ∀a,b,c.R a b → starl A R b c → starl A R a c
+ |refll: ∀a.starl A R a a.
+
+lemma starl_comp : ∀A,R,a,b,c.
+ starl A R a b → R b c → starl A R a c.
+#A #R #a #b #c #Hstar elim Hstar
+ [#a1 #b1 #c1 #Rab #sbc #Hind #a1 @(injl … Rab) @Hind //
+ |#a1 #Rac @(injl … Rac) //
+ ]
+qed.
+
+lemma star_compl : ∀A,R,a,b,c.
+ R a b → star A R b c → star A R a c.
+#A #R #a #b #c #Rab #Hstar elim Hstar
+ [#b1 #c1 #sbb1 #Rb1c1 #Hind @(inj … Rb1c1) @Hind
+ |@(inj … Rab) //
+ ]
+qed.
+
+lemma star_to_starl: ∀A,R,a,b.star A R a b → starl A R a b.
+#A #R #a #b #Hs elim Hs //
+#d #c #sad #Rdc #sad @(starl_comp … Rdc) //
+qed.
+
+lemma starl_to_star: ∀A,R,a,b.starl A R a b → star A R a b.
+#A #R #a #b #Hs elim Hs // -Hs -b -a
+#a #b #c #Rab #sbc #sbc @(star_compl … Rab) //
+qed.
+
+lemma star_ind_l :
+ ∀A:Type[0].∀R:relation A.∀Q:A → A → Prop.
+ (∀a.Q a a) →
+ (∀a,b,c.R a b → star A R b c → Q b c → Q a c) →
+ ∀a,b.star A R a b → Q a b.
+#A #R #Q #H1 #H2 #a #b #H0
+elim (star_to_starl ???? H0) // -H0 -b -a
+#a #b #c #Rab #slbc @H2 // @starl_to_star //
+qed.
+
(* RC and star *)
lemma TC_to_star: ∀A,R,a,b.TC A R a b → star A R a b.