From: Andrea Asperti <andrea.asperti@unibo.it>
Date: Sun, 6 Oct 2013 16:55:51 +0000 (+0000)
Subject: progress in the deifinition of the semantics of the shift move.
X-Git-Tag: make_still_working~1096
X-Git-Url: http://matita.cs.unibo.it/gitweb/?a=commitdiff_plain;h=380e3899d1ed69141d2f828739132ba9a40f664d;p=helm.git

progress in the deifinition of the semantics of the shift move.
--
---

diff --git a/matita/matita/lib/turing/basic_machines.ma b/matita/matita/lib/turing/basic_machines.ma
index f92afc7b9..1e5fa3d2e 100644
--- a/matita/matita/lib/turing/basic_machines.ma
+++ b/matita/matita/lib/turing/basic_machines.ma
@@ -32,7 +32,15 @@ lemma sem_write : ∀alpha,c.Realize ? (write alpha c) (R_write alpha c).
 #alpha #c #t @(ex_intro … 2) @ex_intro
   [|% [% |#ls #c #rs #Ht >Ht % ] ]
 qed. 
- 
+
+definition R_write_strong ≝ λalpha,c,t1,t2.
+  t2 = midtape alpha (left ? t1) c (right ? t1).
+  
+lemma sem_write_strong : ∀alpha,c.Realize ? (write alpha c) (R_write_strong alpha c).
+#alpha #c #t @(ex_intro … 2) @ex_intro
+  [|% [% |cases t normalize // ] ]
+qed. 
+
 (******************** moves the head one step to the right ********************)
 
 definition move_states ≝ initN 2.
@@ -347,4 +355,230 @@ lemma sem_swap_l : ∀alpha,foo.
       [#b #rs #H destruct | #a #b #ls #rs #H destruct normalize //
     ]
   ]
-qed.
\ No newline at end of file
+qed.
+
+(********************************** combine ***********************************)
+(* replace the content x of a cell with a combiation f(x,y) of x and the content
+y of the adiacent cell *)
+
+definition combf_states : FinSet → FinSet ≝ 
+  λalpha:FinSet.FinProd (initN 4) alpha.
+
+definition combf0 : initN 4 ≝ mk_Sig ?? 0 (leb_true_to_le 1 4 (refl …)).
+definition combf1 : initN 4 ≝ mk_Sig ?? 1 (leb_true_to_le 2 4 (refl …)).
+definition combf2 : initN 4 ≝ mk_Sig ?? 2 (leb_true_to_le 3 4 (refl …)).
+definition combf3 : initN 4 ≝ mk_Sig ?? 3 (leb_true_to_le 4 4 (refl …)).
+
+definition combf_r ≝ 
+ λalpha:FinSet.λf.λfoo:alpha.
+ mk_TM alpha (combf_states alpha)
+ (λp.let 〈q,a〉 ≝ p in
+  let 〈q',b〉 ≝ q in
+  let q' ≝ pi1 nat (λi.i<4) q' in
+  match a with 
+  [ None ⇒ 〈〈combf3,foo〉,None ?,N〉 (* if tape is empty then stop *)
+  | Some a' ⇒ 
+  match q' with
+  [ O ⇒ (* q0 *) 〈〈combf1,a'〉,Some ? a',R〉  (* save in register and move R *)
+  | S q' ⇒ match q' with
+    [ O ⇒ (* q1 *) 〈〈combf2,f b a'〉,Some ? a',L〉 
+      (* combine in register and move L *)
+    | S q' ⇒ match q' with
+      [ O ⇒ (* q2 *) 〈〈combf3,foo〉,Some ? b,R〉 
+        (* copy from register and move R *)
+      | S q' ⇒ (* q3 *) 〈〈combf3,foo〉,None ?,N〉 (* final state *)
+      ]
+    ]
+  ]])
+  〈combf0,foo〉
+  (λq.\fst q == combf3).
+  
+definition Rcombf_r ≝ 
+  λalpha,f,t1,t2.
+    (∀b,ls.
+      t1 = midtape alpha ls b [ ] → 
+      t2 = rightof ? b ls) ∧
+    (∀a,b,ls,rs. 
+      t1 = midtape alpha ls b (a::rs) → 
+      t2 = midtape alpha ((f b a)::ls) a rs).
+
+lemma sem_combf_r : ∀alpha,f,foo.
+  combf_r alpha f foo ⊨ Rcombf_r alpha f. 
+#alpha #f #foo *
+  [@(ex_intro ?? 2) @(ex_intro … (mk_config ?? 〈combf3,foo〉 (niltape ?)))
+   % [% |% [#b #ls | #a #b #ls #rs] #H destruct]
+  |#l0 #lt0 @(ex_intro ?? 2) @(ex_intro … (mk_config ?? 〈combf3,foo〉 (leftof ? l0 lt0)))
+   % [% | % [#b #ls | #a #b #ls #rs] #H destruct]
+  |#r0 #rt0 @(ex_intro ?? 2) @(ex_intro … (mk_config ?? 〈combf3,foo〉 (rightof ? r0 rt0)))
+   % [% |% [#b #ls | #a #b #ls #rs] #H destruct] 
+  | #lt #c #rt @(ex_intro ?? 4) cases rt
+    [@ex_intro [|% [ % | %
+      [#b #ls #H destruct normalize // |#a #b #ls #rs #H destruct]]]
+    |#r0 #rt0 @ex_intro [| % [ % | %
+      [#b #ls #H destruct | #a #b #ls #rs #H destruct normalize //
+    ]
+  ]
+qed.
+
+definition combf_l ≝ 
+ λalpha:FinSet.λf.λfoo:alpha.
+ mk_TM alpha (combf_states alpha)
+ (λp.let 〈q,a〉 ≝ p in
+  let 〈q',b〉 ≝ q in
+  let q' ≝ pi1 nat (λi.i<4) q' in
+  match a with 
+  [ None ⇒ 〈〈combf3,foo〉,None ?,N〉 (* if tape is empty then stop *)
+  | Some a' ⇒ 
+  match q' with
+  [ O ⇒ (* q0 *) 〈〈combf1,a'〉,Some ? a',L〉  (* save in register and move R *)
+  | S q' ⇒ match q' with
+    [ O ⇒ (* q1 *) 〈〈combf2,f b a'〉,Some ? a',R〉 
+      (* combine in register and move L *)
+    | S q' ⇒ match q' with
+      [ O ⇒ (* q2 *) 〈〈combf3,foo〉,Some ? b,L〉 
+        (* copy from register and move R *)
+      | S q' ⇒ (* q3 *) 〈〈combf3,foo〉,None ?,N〉 (* final state *)
+      ]
+    ]
+  ]])
+  〈combf0,foo〉
+  (λq.\fst q == combf3).
+  
+definition Rcombf_l ≝ 
+  λalpha,f,t1,t2.
+    (∀b,rs.
+      t1 = midtape alpha [ ] b rs → 
+      t2 = leftof ? b rs) ∧
+    (∀a,b,ls,rs. 
+      t1 = midtape alpha (a::ls) b rs → 
+      t2 = midtape alpha ls a ((f b a)::rs)).
+
+lemma sem_combf_l : ∀alpha,f,foo.
+  combf_l alpha f foo ⊨ Rcombf_l alpha f. 
+#alpha #f #foo *
+  [@(ex_intro ?? 2) @(ex_intro … (mk_config ?? 〈combf3,foo〉 (niltape ?)))
+   % [% |% [#b #ls | #a #b #ls #rs] #H destruct]
+  |#l0 #lt0 @(ex_intro ?? 2) @(ex_intro … (mk_config ?? 〈combf3,foo〉 (leftof ? l0 lt0)))
+   % [% | % [#b #ls | #a #b #ls #rs] #H destruct]
+  |#r0 #rt0 @(ex_intro ?? 2) @(ex_intro … (mk_config ?? 〈combf3,foo〉 (rightof ? r0 rt0)))
+   % [% |% [#b #ls | #a #b #ls #rs] #H destruct] 
+  | #lt #c #rt @(ex_intro ?? 4) cases lt
+    [@ex_intro [|% [ % | %
+      [#b #ls #H destruct normalize // |#a #b #ls #rs #H destruct]]]
+    |#r0 #rt0 @ex_intro [| % [ % | %
+      [#b #ls #H destruct | #a #b #ls #rs #H destruct normalize //
+    ]
+  ]
+qed.
+
+(********************************* new_combine ********************************)
+(* replace the content x of a cell with a combiation f(x,y) of x and the content
+y of the adiacent cell; if there is no adjacent cell, combines with a default 
+value foo *)
+
+definition ncombf_r ≝ 
+ λalpha:FinSet.λf.λfoo:alpha.
+ mk_TM alpha (combf_states alpha)
+ (λp.let 〈q,a〉 ≝ p in
+  let 〈q',b〉 ≝ q in
+  let q' ≝ pi1 nat (λi.i<4) q' in
+  match a with 
+  [ None ⇒ if (eqb q' 1)then (* if on right cell, combine in register and move L *) 
+           〈〈combf2,f b foo〉,None ?,L〉
+           else 〈〈combf3,foo〉,None ?,N〉 (* else stop *)
+  | Some a' ⇒ 
+  match q' with
+  [ O ⇒ (* q0 *) 〈〈combf1,a'〉,Some ? a',R〉  (* save in register and move R *)
+  | S q' ⇒ match q' with
+    [ O ⇒ (* q1 *) 〈〈combf2,f b a'〉,Some ? a',L〉 
+      (* combine in register and move L *)
+    | S q' ⇒ match q' with
+      [ O ⇒ (* q2 *) 〈〈combf3,foo〉,Some ? b,R〉 
+        (* copy from register and move R *)
+      | S q' ⇒ (* q3 *) 〈〈combf3,foo〉,None ?,N〉 (* final state *)
+      ]
+    ]
+  ]])
+  〈combf0,foo〉
+  (λq.\fst q == combf3).
+  
+definition Rncombf_r ≝ 
+  λalpha,f,foo,t1,t2.
+    (∀b,ls.
+      t1 = midtape alpha ls b [ ] → 
+      t2 = rightof ? (f b foo) ls) ∧
+    (∀a,b,ls,rs. 
+      t1 = midtape alpha ls b (a::rs) → 
+      t2 = midtape alpha ((f b a)::ls) a rs).
+
+lemma sem_ncombf_r : ∀alpha,f,foo.
+  ncombf_r alpha f foo ⊨ Rncombf_r alpha f foo. 
+#alpha #f #foo *
+  [@(ex_intro ?? 2) @(ex_intro … (mk_config ?? 〈combf3,foo〉 (niltape ?)))
+   % [% |% [#b #ls | #a #b #ls #rs] #H destruct]
+  |#l0 #lt0 @(ex_intro ?? 2) @(ex_intro … (mk_config ?? 〈combf3,foo〉 (leftof ? l0 lt0)))
+   % [% | % [#b #ls | #a #b #ls #rs] #H destruct]
+  |#r0 #rt0 @(ex_intro ?? 2) @(ex_intro … (mk_config ?? 〈combf3,foo〉 (rightof ? r0 rt0)))
+   % [% |% [#b #ls | #a #b #ls #rs] #H destruct] 
+  | #lt #c #rt @(ex_intro ?? 4) cases rt
+    [@ex_intro [|% [ % | %
+      [#b #ls #H destruct normalize // |#a #b #ls #rs #H destruct]]]
+    |#r0 #rt0 @ex_intro [| % [ % | %
+      [#b #ls #H destruct | #a #b #ls #rs #H destruct normalize //
+    ]
+  ]
+qed.
+
+definition ncombf_l ≝ 
+ λalpha:FinSet.λf.λfoo:alpha.
+ mk_TM alpha (combf_states alpha)
+ (λp.let 〈q,a〉 ≝ p in
+  let 〈q',b〉 ≝ q in
+  let q' ≝ pi1 nat (λi.i<4) q' in
+  match a with 
+  [ None ⇒ if (eqb q' 1)then 
+           (* if on left cell, combine in register and move R *) 
+           〈〈combf2,f b foo〉,None ?,R〉
+           else 〈〈combf3,foo〉,None ?,N〉 (* else stop *)
+  | Some a' ⇒ 
+  match q' with
+  [ O ⇒ (* q0 *) 〈〈combf1,a'〉,Some ? a',L〉  (* save in register and move R *)
+  | S q' ⇒ match q' with
+    [ O ⇒ (* q1 *) 〈〈combf2,f b a'〉,Some ? a',R〉 
+      (* combine in register and move L *)
+    | S q' ⇒ match q' with
+      [ O ⇒ (* q2 *) 〈〈combf3,foo〉,Some ? b,L〉 
+        (* copy from register and move R *)
+      | S q' ⇒ (* q3 *) 〈〈combf3,foo〉,None ?,N〉 (* final state *)
+      ]
+    ]
+  ]])
+  〈combf0,foo〉
+  (λq.\fst q == combf3).
+  
+definition Rncombf_l ≝ 
+  λalpha,f,foo,t1,t2.
+    (∀b,rs.
+      t1 = midtape alpha [ ] b rs → 
+      t2 = leftof ? (f b foo) rs) ∧
+    (∀a,b,ls,rs. 
+      t1 = midtape alpha (a::ls) b rs → 
+      t2 = midtape alpha ls a ((f b a)::rs)).
+
+lemma sem_ncombf_l : ∀alpha,f,foo.
+  ncombf_l alpha f foo ⊨ Rncombf_l alpha f foo. 
+#alpha #f #foo *
+  [@(ex_intro ?? 2) @(ex_intro … (mk_config ?? 〈combf3,foo〉 (niltape ?)))
+   % [% |% [#b #ls | #a #b #ls #rs] #H destruct]
+  |#l0 #lt0 @(ex_intro ?? 2) @(ex_intro … (mk_config ?? 〈combf3,foo〉 (leftof ? l0 lt0)))
+   % [% | % [#b #ls | #a #b #ls #rs] #H destruct]
+  |#r0 #rt0 @(ex_intro ?? 2) @(ex_intro … (mk_config ?? 〈combf3,foo〉 (rightof ? r0 rt0)))
+   % [% |% [#b #ls | #a #b #ls #rs] #H destruct] 
+  | #lt #c #rt @(ex_intro ?? 4) cases lt
+    [@ex_intro [|% [ % | %
+      [#b #ls #H destruct normalize // |#a #b #ls #rs #H destruct]]]
+    |#r0 #rt0 @ex_intro [| % [ % | %
+      [#b #ls #H destruct | #a #b #ls #rs #H destruct normalize //
+    ]
+  ]
+qed.
diff --git a/matita/matita/lib/turing/if_machine.ma b/matita/matita/lib/turing/if_machine.ma
index 27e81f549..3c6d686ea 100644
--- a/matita/matita/lib/turing/if_machine.ma
+++ b/matita/matita/lib/turing/if_machine.ma
@@ -222,6 +222,20 @@ cases (true_or_false (cstate ?? outc1 == acc)) #Hacc
   ]
 qed.
 
+lemma sem_if_app: ∀sig,M1,M2,M3,Rtrue,Rfalse,R2,R3,R4,acc.
+  accRealize sig M1 acc Rtrue Rfalse  → M2 ⊨ R2  → M3 ⊨ R3 →  
+    (∀t1,t2,t3. (Rtrue t1 t3 ∧ R2 t3 t2) ∨ (Rfalse t1 t3 ∧ R3 t3 t2) → R4 t1 t2) → 
+    ifTM sig M1 M2 M3 acc ⊨ R4.
+#sig #M1 #M2 #M3 #Rtrue #Rfalse #R2 #R3 #R4 #acc
+#HRacc #HRtrue #HRfalse #Hsub
+#t cases (sem_if … HRacc HRtrue HRfalse t)
+#k * #outc * #Hloop #Houtc @(ex_intro … k) @(ex_intro … outc)
+% [@Hloop] cases Houtc
+  [* #t3 * #Hleft #Hright @(Hsub … t3) %1 /2/
+  |* #t3 * #Hleft #Hright @(Hsub … t3) %2 /2/ ]
+qed.
+
+(* weak 
 lemma sem_if_app: ∀sig,M1,M2,M3,Rtrue,Rfalse,R2,R3,R4,acc.
   accRealize sig M1 acc Rtrue Rfalse  → M2 ⊨ R2  → M3 ⊨ R3 →  
     (∀t1,t2,t3. (Rtrue t1 t3 → R2 t3 t2) ∨ (Rfalse t1 t3 → R3 t3 t2) → R4 t1 t2) → 
@@ -234,7 +248,8 @@ lemma sem_if_app: ∀sig,M1,M2,M3,Rtrue,Rfalse,R2,R3,R4,acc.
   [* #t3 * #Hleft #Hright @(Hsub … t3) %1 /2/
   |* #t3 * #Hleft #Hright @(Hsub … t3) %2 /2/ ]
 qed.
- 
+*)
+
 (* we can probably use acc_sem_if to prove sem_if *)
 (* for sure we can use acc_sem_if_guarded to prove acc_sem_if *)
 lemma acc_sem_if: ∀sig,M1,M2,M3,Rtrue,Rfalse,R2,R3,acc.
diff --git a/matita/matita/lib/turing/mono.ma b/matita/matita/lib/turing/mono.ma
index 6a006d581..a0358aa2d 100644
--- a/matita/matita/lib/turing/mono.ma
+++ b/matita/matita/lib/turing/mono.ma
@@ -9,6 +9,7 @@
      \ /   GNU General Public License Version 2   
       V_____________________________________________________________*)
 
+include "basics/finset.ma".
 include "basics/vectors.ma".
 include "basics/finset.ma".
 (* include "basics/relations.ma". *)
diff --git a/matita/matita/lib/turing/multi_to_mono.ma b/matita/matita/lib/turing/multi_to_mono.ma
new file mode 100644
index 000000000..2af23367b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/matita/matita/lib/turing/multi_to_mono.ma
@@ -0,0 +1,494 @@
+include "turing/basic_machines.ma".
+include "turing/if_machine.ma".
+include "basics/vector_finset.ma".
+include "turing/auxiliary_machines1.ma".
+
+(* a multi_sig characheter is composed by n+1 sub-characters: n for each tape 
+of a multitape machine, and an additional one to mark the position of the head. 
+We extend the tape alphabet with two new symbols true and false. 
+false is used to pad shorter tapes, and true to mark the head of the tape *)
+
+definition sig_ext ≝ λsig. FinSum FinBool sig.
+definition blank : ∀sig.sig_ext sig ≝ λsig. inl … false.
+definition head : ∀sig.sig_ext sig ≝ λsig. inl … true.
+
+definition multi_sig ≝ λsig:FinSet.λn.FinVector (sig_ext sig) n.
+
+let rec all_blank sig n on n : multi_sig sig n ≝ 
+  match n with
+  [ O ⇒ Vector_of_list ? []
+  | S m ⇒ vec_cons ? (blank ?) m (all_blank sig m)
+  ].
+
+lemma blank_all_blank: ∀sig,n,i. i ≤ n →
+  nth i ? (vec … (all_blank sig n)) (blank sig) = blank ?.
+#sig #n elim n normalize
+  [#i #lei0 @(le_n_O_elim … lei0) normalize // 
+  |#m #Hind #i cases i // #j #lej @Hind @le_S_S_to_le //
+  ]
+qed.
+
+lemma all_blank_n: ∀sig,n.
+  nth n ? (vec … (all_blank sig n)) (blank sig) = blank ?.
+#sig #n @blank_all_blank //
+qed.
+
+
+(* a machine that moves the i trace r: we reach the left margin of the i-trace 
+and make a (shifted) copy of the old tape up to the end of the right margin of 
+the i-trace. Then come back to the origin. *)
+
+(* definition move_r_i *)
+
+(* move_tape_i_step:
+   we cycle on normal chars *)
+definition shift_i ≝ λsig,n,i.λa,b:Vector (sig_ext sig) n.
+  change_vec (sig_ext sig) n a (nth i ? b (blank ?)) i.
+
+(* vec is a coercion. Why should I insert it? *)
+definition mti_step ≝ λsig:FinSet.λn,i.
+  ifTM (multi_sig sig n) (test_char ? (λc:multi_sig sig n.¬(nth i ? (vec … c) (blank ?))==blank ?))
+     (single_finalTM … (ncombf_r (multi_sig sig n) (shift_i sig n i) (all_blank sig n)))
+     (nop ?) tc_true.
+      
+definition Rmti_step_true ≝ 
+λsig,n,i,t1,t2. 
+  ∃b:multi_sig sig n. (nth i ? (vec … b) (blank ?) ≠ blank ?) ∧
+    ((∃ls,a,rs.
+       t1 = midtape (multi_sig sig n) ls b (a::rs) ∧
+       t2 = midtape (multi_sig sig n) ((shift_i sig n i b a)::ls) a rs) ∨
+     (∃ls.
+       t1 = midtape ? ls b [] ∧
+       t2 = rightof ? (shift_i sig n i b (all_blank sig n)) ls)).
+
+(* 〈combf0,all_blank sig n〉 *)
+definition Rmti_step_false ≝ 
+  λsig,n,i,t1,t2.
+    (∀ls,b,rs. t1 = midtape (multi_sig sig n) ls b rs →
+     (nth i ? (vec … b) (blank ?) = blank ?)) ∧ t2 = t1.
+
+lemma sem_mti_step :
+  ∀sig,n,i.
+  mti_step sig n i  ⊨ 
+    [inr … (inl … (inr … start_nop)): Rmti_step_true sig n i, Rmti_step_false sig n i].
+#sig #n #i
+@(acc_sem_if_app (multi_sig sig n) ?????????? 
+     (sem_test_char …) (sem_ncombf_r (multi_sig sig n) (shift_i sig n i)(all_blank sig n)) 
+     (sem_nop (multi_sig sig n)))
+  [#intape #outtape #tapea whd in ⊢ (%→%→%); * * #c *
+   #Hcur cases (current_to_midtape … Hcur) #ls * #rs #Hintape
+   #ctest #Htapea * #Hout1 #Hout2 @(ex_intro … c) %
+    [@(\Pf (injective_notb … )) @ctest]
+   generalize in match Hintape; -Hintape cases rs
+    [#Hintape %2 @(ex_intro …ls) % // @Hout1 >Htapea @Hintape
+    |#a #rs1 #Hintape %1
+     @(ex_intro … ls) @(ex_intro … a) @(ex_intro … rs1) % //
+     @Hout2 >Htapea @Hintape
+    ]
+  |#intape #outtape #tapea whd in ⊢ (%→%→%);
+   * #Htest #tapea #outtape 
+   % // #ls #b #rs
+   #intape lapply (Htest b ?) [>intape //] -Htest #Htest 
+   lapply (injective_notb ? true Htest) -Htest #Htest @(\P Htest) 
+  ]   
+qed.
+      
+(* move tape i machine *)
+definition mti ≝ 
+  λsig,n,i.whileTM (multi_sig sig n) (mti_step sig n i) (inr … (inl … (inr … start_nop))). 
+
+(* v2 is obtained from v1 shifting left the i-th trace *)
+definition shift_l ≝ λsig,n,i,v1,v2.  (* multi_sig sig n*) 
+  |v1| = |v2| ∧ ∀j. S j < |v1| → 
+    nth j ? v2 (all_blank sig n) = 
+      change_vec ? n (nth j ? v1 (all_blank sig n)) 
+        (nth i ? (vec … (nth (S j) ? v1 (all_blank sig n))) (blank ?)) i.
+
+axiom daemon: ∀P:Prop.P.
+
+definition R_mti ≝ 
+  λsig,n,i,t1,t2.
+    (∀a,rs. t1 = rightof ? a rs → t2 = t1) ∧
+    (∀a,ls,rs. 
+      t1 = midtape (multi_sig sig n) ls a rs → 
+      (nth i ? (vec … a) (blank ?) = blank ? ∧ t2 = t1) ∨
+      ((∃rs1,b,rs2,rss.
+        rs = rs1@b::rs2 ∧ 
+        nth i ? (vec … b) (blank ?) = (blank ?) ∧
+        (∀x. mem ? x (a::rs1) → nth i ? (vec … x) (blank ?) ≠ (blank ?)) ∧
+        shift_l sig n i (a::rs1) rss ∧
+        t2 = midtape (multi_sig sig n) ((reverse ? rss)@ls) b rs2) ∨
+      (∃b,rss. 
+        (∀x. mem ? x (a::rs) → nth i ? (vec … x) (blank ?) ≠ (blank ?)) ∧
+        shift_l sig n i (a::rs) (rss@[b]) ∧
+        t2 = rightof (multi_sig sig n) (shift_i sig n i b (all_blank sig n)) 
+         ((reverse ? rss)@ls)))).  
+
+lemma sem_mti:
+  ∀sig,n,i.
+  WRealize (multi_sig sig n) (mti sig n i) (R_mti sig n i).
+#sig #n #i #inc #j #outc #Hloop
+lapply (sem_while … (sem_mti_step sig n i) inc j outc Hloop) [%]
+-Hloop * #t1 * #Hstar @(star_ind_l ??????? Hstar)
+[ whd in ⊢ (% → ?); * #H1 #H2 % 
+  [#a #rs #Htape1 @H2
+  |#a #ls #rs #Htapea % % [@(H1 … Htapea) |@H2]
+  ]
+| #tapeb #tapec #Hstar1 #HRtrue #IH #HRfalse
+  lapply (IH HRfalse) -IH -HRfalse whd in ⊢ (%→%); 
+  * #IH1 #IH2 %
+  [#b0 #ls #Htapeb cases Hstar1 #b * #_ *
+    [* #ls0 * #a * #rs0 * >Htapeb #H destruct (H)
+    |* #ls0 * >Htapeb #H destruct (H)
+    ]
+  |#b0 #ls #rs #Htapeb cases Hstar1 #b * #btest *
+  [* #ls1 * #a * #rs1 * >Htapeb #H destruct (H) #Htapec 
+   %2 cases (IH2 … Htapec)
+    [(* case a = None *)
+     * #testa #Hout %1
+     %{[ ]} %{a} %{rs1} %{[shift_i sig n i b a]} %
+      [%[%[% // |#x #Hb >(mem_single ??? Hb) // ] 
+        |@daemon]
+      |>Hout >reverse_single @Htapec
+      ] 
+    |*
+      [ (* case a \= None and exists b = None *) -IH1 -IH2 #IH
+        %1 cases IH -IH #rs10 * #b0 * #rs2 * #rss * * * *
+        #H1 #H2 #H3 #H4 #H5
+        %{(a::rs10)} %{b0} %{rs2} %{(shift_i sig n i b a::rss)}
+        %[%[%[%[>H1 //|@H2]
+            |#x * [#eqxa >eqxa (*?? *) @daemon|@H3]]
+          |@daemon]
+        |>H5 >reverse_cons >associative_append //
+        ]
+      | (* case a \= None and we reach the end of the (full) tape *) -IH1 -IH2 #IH
+        %2 cases IH -IH #b0 * #rss * * #H1 #H2 #H3
+        %{b0} %{(shift_i sig n i b a::rss)} 
+        %[%[#x * [#eqxb >eqxb @btest|@H1]
+           |@daemon]
+        |>H3 >reverse_cons >associative_append //
+        ]
+      ]
+    ]
+  |(* b \= None but the left tape is empty *)
+   * #ls0 * >Htapeb #H destruct (H) #Htapec
+   %2 %2 %{b} %{[ ]} 
+   %[%[#x * [#eqxb >eqxb @btest|@False_ind]
+      |@daemon (*shift of  dingle char OK *)]
+    |>(IH1 … Htapec) >Htapec //
+    ]
+  ]
+qed.
+    
+lemma WF_mti_niltape:
+  ∀sig,n,i. WF ? (inv ? (Rmti_step_true sig n i)) (niltape ?).
+#sig #n #i @wf #t1 whd in ⊢ (%→?); * #b * #_ *
+  [* #ls * #a * #rs * #H destruct|* #ls * #H destruct ]
+qed.
+
+lemma WF_mti_rightof:
+  ∀sig,n,i,a,ls. WF ? (inv ? (Rmti_step_true sig n i)) (rightof ? a ls).
+#sig #n #i #a #ls @wf #t1 whd in ⊢ (%→?); * #b * #_ *
+  [* #ls * #a * #rs * #H destruct|* #ls * #H destruct ]
+qed.
+
+lemma WF_mti_leftof:
+  ∀sig,n,i,a,ls. WF ? (inv ? (Rmti_step_true sig n i)) (leftof ? a ls).
+#sig #n #i #a #ls @wf #t1 whd in ⊢ (%→?); * #b * #_ *
+  [* #ls * #a * #rs * #H destruct|* #ls * #H destruct ]
+qed.
+
+lemma terminate_mti:
+  ∀sig,n,i.∀t. Terminate ? (mti sig n i) t.
+#sig #n #i #t @(terminate_while … (sem_mti_step sig n i)) [%]
+cases t // #ls #c #rs lapply c -c lapply ls -ls  elim rs 
+  [#ls #c @wf #t1 whd in ⊢ (%→?); * #b * #_ *
+    [* #ls1 * #a * #rs1 * #H destruct
+    |* #ls1 * #H destruct #Ht1 >Ht1 //
+    ]
+  |#a #rs1 #Hind #ls #c @wf #t1 whd in ⊢ (%→?); * #b * #_ *
+    [* #ls1 * #a2 * #rs2 * #H destruct (H) #Ht1 >Ht1 //
+    |* #ls1 *  #H destruct
+    ]
+  ]
+qed.
+
+lemma ssem_mti: ∀sig,n,i.
+  Realize ? (mti sig n i) (R_mti sig n i).
+/2/ qed.
+   
+(******************************************************************************)
+(* mtiL: complete move L for tape i. We reaching the left border of trace i,  *)
+(* add a blank if there is no more tape, then move the i-trace and finally    *)
+(* come back to the head position.                                            *)
+(******************************************************************************)
+
+definition no_blank ≝ λsig,n,i.λc:multi_sig sig n.
+  ¬(nth i ? (vec … c) (blank ?))==blank ?.
+
+definition no_head ≝ λsig,n.λc:multi_sig sig n.
+  ¬((nth n ? (vec … c) (blank ?))==head ?).
+
+definition mtiL ≝ λsig,n,i.
+   move_until ? L (no_blank sig n i) · 
+   extend ? (all_blank sig n) ·
+   ncombf_r (multi_sig …) (shift_i sig n i) (all_blank sig n) ·
+   mti sig n i · 
+   extend ? (all_blank sig n) ·
+   move_until ? L (no_head sig n). 
+   
+let rec to_blank sig n i l on l ≝
+  match l with
+  [ nil ⇒  [ ]
+  | cons a tl ⇒ 
+      let ai ≝ nth i ? (vec … n a) (blank sig) in
+      if ai == blank ? then [ ] else ai::(to_blank sig n i tl)]. 
+      
+lemma to_blank_cons_b : ∀sig,n,i,a,l.
+  nth i ? (vec … n a) (blank sig) = blank ? →
+  to_blank sig n i (a::l) = [ ].
+#sig #n #i #a #l #H whd in match (to_blank ????);
+>(\b H) //
+qed.      
+
+lemma to_blank_cons_nb: ∀sig,n,i,a,l.
+  nth i ? (vec … n a) (blank sig) ≠ blank ? →
+  to_blank sig n i (a::l) = 
+    nth i ? (vec … n a) (blank sig)::(to_blank sig n i l).
+#sig #n #i #a #l #H whd in match (to_blank ????);
+>(\bf H) //
+qed.
+
+(******************************* move_to_blank_L ******************************)
+(* we compose machines together to reduce the number of output cases, and 
+   improve semantics *)
+   
+definition move_to_blank_L ≝ λsig,n,i.
+  (move_until ? L (no_blank sig n i)) · extend ? (all_blank sig n).
+  
+definition R_move_to_blank_L ≝ λsig,n,i,t1,t2.
+(current ? t1 = None ? → 
+  t2 = midtape (multi_sig sig n) (left ? t1) (all_blank …) (right ? t1)) ∧
+∀ls,a,rs.t1 = midtape ? ls a rs → 
+  ((no_blank sig n i a = false) ∧ t2 = t1) ∨
+  (∃b,ls1,ls2.
+    (no_blank sig n i b = false) ∧ 
+    (∀j.j ≤n → to_blank ?? j (ls1@b::ls2) = to_blank ?? j ls) ∧
+    t2 = midtape ? ls2 b ((reverse ? (a::ls1))@rs)).
+
+theorem sem_move_to_blank_L: ∀sig,n,i. 
+  move_to_blank_L sig n i  ⊨ R_move_to_blank_L sig n i.
+#sig #n #i 
+@(sem_seq_app ?????? 
+  (ssem_move_until_L ? (no_blank sig n i)) (sem_extend ? (all_blank sig n)))
+#tin #tout * #t1 * * #Ht1a #Ht1b * #Ht2a #Ht2b %
+  [#Hcur >(Ht1a Hcur) in Ht2a; /2 by /
+  |#ls #a #rs #Htin -Ht1a cases (Ht1b … Htin)
+    [* #Hnb #Ht1 -Ht1b -Ht2a >Ht1 in Ht2b; >Htin #H %1 
+     % [//|@H normalize % #H1 destruct (H1)] 
+    |* 
+    [(* we find the blank *)
+     * #ls1 * #b * #ls2 * * * #H1 #H2 #H3 #H4 %2
+     %{b} %{ls1} %{ls2} 
+     %[%[@H2|>H1 //] 
+      |-Ht1b -Ht2a >H4 in Ht2b; #H5 @H5
+       % normalize #H6 destruct (H6)
+      ]
+    |* #b * #lss * * #H1 #H2 #H3 %2
+     %{(all_blank …)} %{ls} %{[ ]} 
+     %[%[whd in match (no_blank ????); >blank_all_blank // @daemon
+        |@daemon (* make a lemma *)] 
+      |-Ht1b -Ht2b >H3 in Ht2a; 
+       whd in match (left ??); whd in match (right ??); #H4
+       >H2 >reverse_append >reverse_single @H4 normalize // 
+      ]
+    ]
+  ]
+qed.
+
+(******************************************************************************)
+
+definition shift_i_L ≝ λsig,n,i.
+   ncombf_r (multi_sig …) (shift_i sig n i) (all_blank sig n) ·
+   mti sig n i · 
+   extend ? (all_blank sig n).
+   
+definition R_shift_i_L ≝ λsig,n,i,t1,t2.
+  (* ∀b:multi_sig sig n.∀ls.
+    (t1 = midtape ? ls b [ ] → 
+     t2 = midtape (multi_sig sig n) 
+      ((shift_i sig n i b (all_blank sig n))::ls) (all_blank sig n) [ ]) ∧ *)
+    (∀a,ls,rs. 
+      t1 = midtape ? ls a rs  → 
+      ((∃rs1,b,rs2,rss.
+        rs = rs1@b::rs2 ∧ 
+        nth i ? (vec … b) (blank ?) = (blank ?) ∧
+        (∀x. mem ? x rs1 → nth i ? (vec … x) (blank ?) ≠ (blank ?)) ∧
+        shift_l sig n i (a::rs1) rss ∧
+        t2 = midtape (multi_sig sig n) ((reverse ? rss)@ls) b rs2) ∨
+      (∃b,rss. 
+        (∀x. mem ? x rs → nth i ? (vec … x) (blank ?) ≠ (blank ?)) ∧
+        shift_l sig n i (a::rs) (rss@[b]) ∧
+        t2 = midtape (multi_sig sig n) 
+          ((reverse ? (rss@[b]))@ls) (all_blank sig n) [ ]))).
+
+theorem sem_shift_i_L: ∀sig,n,i. shift_i_L sig n i  ⊨ R_shift_i_L sig n i.
+#sig #n #i 
+@(sem_seq_app ?????? 
+  (sem_ncombf_r (multi_sig sig n) (shift_i sig n i)(all_blank sig n))
+   (sem_seq ????? (ssem_mti sig n i) 
+    (sem_extend ? (all_blank sig n))))
+#tin #tout * #t1 * * #Ht1a #Ht1b * #t2 * * #Ht2a #Ht2b * #Htout1 #Htout2
+(* #b #ls %
+  [#Htin lapply (Ht1a … Htin) -Ht1a -Ht1b #Ht1 
+   lapply (Ht2a … Ht1) -Ht2a -Ht2b #Ht2 >Ht2 in Htout1; 
+   >Ht1 whd in match (left ??); whd in match (right ??); #Htout @Htout // *)
+#a #ls #rs cases rs
+  [#Htin %2 %{(shift_i sig n i a (all_blank sig n))} %{[ ]} 
+   %[%[#x @False_ind | @daemon]
+    |lapply (Ht1a … Htin) -Ht1a -Ht1b #Ht1 
+     lapply (Ht2a … Ht1) -Ht2a -Ht2b #Ht2 >Ht2 in Htout1; 
+     >Ht1 whd in match (left ??); whd in match (right ??); #Htout @Htout // 
+    ]
+  |#a1 #rs1 #Htin 
+   lapply (Ht1b … Htin) -Ht1a -Ht1b #Ht1 
+   lapply (Ht2b … Ht1) -Ht2a -Ht2b *
+    [(* a1 is blank *) * #H1 #H2 %1
+     %{[ ]} %{a1} %{rs1} %{[shift_i sig n i a a1]}
+     %[%[%[%[// |//] |#x @False_ind] | @daemon]
+      |>Htout2 [>H2 >reverse_single @Ht1 |>H2 >Ht1 normalize % #H destruct (H)]
+      ]
+    |*
+    [* #rs10 * #b * #rs2 * #rss * * * * #H1 #H2 #H3 #H4
+     #Ht2 %1 
+     %{(a1::rs10)} %{b} %{rs2} %{(shift_i sig n i a a1::rss)}
+     %[%[%[%[>H1 //|//] |@H3] |@daemon ]
+      |>reverse_cons >associative_append 
+       >H2 in Htout2; #Htout >Htout [@Ht2| >Ht2 normalize % #H destruct (H)]  
+      ]
+    |* #b * #rss * * #H1 #H2 
+     #Ht2 %2
+     %{(shift_i sig n i b (all_blank sig n))} %{(shift_i sig n i a a1::rss)}
+     %[%[@H1 |@daemon ]
+      |>Ht2 in Htout1; #Htout >Htout //
+       whd in match (left ??); whd in match (right ??);
+       >reverse_append >reverse_single >associative_append  >reverse_cons
+       >associative_append // 
+       ]
+     ]
+   ]
+ ]
+qed.
+ 
+    
+definition Rmtil ≝ λsig,n,i,t1,t2.
+  ∀ls,a,rs. 
+   t1 = midtape ? ls a rs → 
+   nth n ? (vec … a) (blank ?) = head ? →   
+   (∀x.mem ? x ls → no_head sig n x = true) →   
+   (∀x.mem ? x rs → no_head sig n x = true) → 
+   (∃ls1,a1,rs1.
+     t2 = midtape (multi_sig …) ls1 a1 rs1 ∧
+     (∀j. j ≤ n → j ≠ i → to_blank ? n j ls1 = to_blank ? n j ls) ∧
+     (∀j. j ≤ n → j ≠ i → to_blank ? n j rs1 = to_blank ? n j rs) ∧
+     (nth i ? (vec … a) (blank ?) = blank ? → ls1 = ls) ∧
+     (nth i ? (vec … a) (blank ?) ≠ blank ? → to_blank ? n i ls1 = nth i ? (vec … a) (blank ?)::to_blank ? n i ls) ∧
+     (to_blank ? n i (a1::rs1)) = to_blank ? n i rs).
+
+theorem sem_Rmtil: ∀sig,n,i. mtiL sig n i  ⊨ Rmtil sig n i.
+#sig #n #i 
+@(sem_seq_app ?????? 
+  (ssem_move_until_L ? (no_blank sig n i))
+   (sem_seq ????? (sem_extend ? (all_blank sig n))
+    (sem_seq ????? (sem_ncombf_r (multi_sig sig n) (shift_i sig n i)(all_blank sig n))
+     (sem_seq ????? (ssem_mti sig n i) 
+      (sem_seq ????? (sem_extend ? (all_blank sig n)) 
+       (ssem_move_until_L ? (no_head sig n)))))))
+#tin #tout * #t1 * * #_ #Ht1 * #t2 * * #Ht2a #Ht2b * #t3 * * #Ht3a #Ht3b 
+* #t4 * * #Ht4a #Ht4b * #t5 * * #Ht5a #Ht5b * #t6 #Htout
+(* we start looking into Rmitl *)
+#ls #a #rs #Htin (* tin is a midtape *)
+#Hhead #Hnohead_ls #Hnohead_rs  
+cases (Ht1 … Htin) -Ht1 
+  [(* the current character on trace i is blank *)
+   -Ht2a * #Hblank #Ht1 <Ht1 in Htin; #Ht1a >Ht1a in Ht2b;
+   #Ht2b lapply (Ht2b ?) [% normalize #H destruct] -Ht2b -Ht1 -Ht1a 
+   lapply Hnohead_rs -Hnohead_rs
+   (* by cases on rs *) cases rs
+    [#_ (* rs is empty *) #Ht2 -Ht3b lapply (Ht3a … Ht2)
+     #Ht3 -Ht4b lapply (Ht4a … Ht3) -Ht4a #Ht4 -Ht5b
+     >Ht4 in Ht5a; >Ht3 #Ht5a lapply (Ht5a (refl … )) -Ht5a #Ht5
+     cases (Htout … Ht5) -Htout
+      [(* the current symbol on trace n is the head: this is absurd *)
+       * whd in ⊢ (??%?→?); >all_blank_n whd in ⊢ (??%?→?); #H destruct (H)
+      |*
+      [(* we return to the head *)
+       * #ls1 * #b * #ls2 * * * whd in ⊢ (??%?→?);
+       #H1 #H2 #H3 
+       (* ls1 must be empty *)
+       cut (ls1=[]) 
+        [lapply H3 lapply H1 -H3 -H1 cases ls1 // #c #ls3
+         whd in ⊢ (???%→?); #H1 destruct (H1) 
+         >blank_all_blank [|@daemon] #H @False_ind 
+         lapply (H … (change_vec (sig_ext sig) n a (blank sig) i) ?) 
+          [%2 %1 // | whd in match (no_head ???); >nth_change_vec_neq [|@daemon]
+           >Hhead whd in ⊢ (??%?→?); #H1 destruct (H1)]] 
+       #Hls1_nil >Hls1_nil in H1; whd in ⊢ (???%→?); #H destruct (H)
+       >reverse_single >blank_all_blank [|@daemon]
+       whd in match (right ??) ; >append_nil #Htout
+       %{ls2} %{(change_vec (sig_ext sig) n a (blank sig) i)} %{[all_blank sig n]}
+       %[%[%[%[%[//|//]|@daemon]|//] |(*absurd*)@daemon] 
+        |normalize >nth_change_vec // @daemon]
+      |(* we do not find the head: this is absurd *)
+       * #b * #lss * * whd in match (left ??); #HF @False_ind
+       lapply (HF … (shift_i sig n i a (all_blank sig n)) ?) [%2 %1 //] 
+       whd in match (no_head ???); >nth_change_vec_neq [|@daemon]
+       >Hhead whd in ⊢ (??%?→?); #H destruct (H)
+      ]
+      ]
+    |(* rs = c::rs1 *)
+     #c #rs1 #Hnohead_rs #Ht2 -Ht3a lapply (Ht3b … Ht2) -Ht3b
+     #Ht3 -Ht4a lapply (Ht4b … Ht3) -Ht4b *
+      [(* the first character is blank *) *
+       #Hblank #Ht4 -Ht5a >Ht4 in Ht5b; >Ht3 
+       normalize in ⊢ ((%→?)→?); #Ht5 lapply (Ht5 ?) [% #H destruct (H)] 
+       -Ht2 -Ht3 -Ht4 -Ht5 #Ht5 cases (Htout … Ht5) -Htout
+        [(* the current symbol on trace n is the head: this is absurd *)
+         * >Hnohead_rs [#H destruct (H) |%1 //]
+        |*
+        [(* we return to the head *)
+         * #ls1 * #b * #ls2 * * * whd in ⊢ (??%?→?);
+         #H1 #H2 #H3 
+         (* ls1 must be empty *)
+         cut (ls1=[]) 
+          [lapply H3 lapply H1 -H3 -H1 cases ls1 // #x #ls3
+           whd in ⊢ (???%→?); #H1 destruct (H1) #H @False_ind
+           lapply (H (change_vec (sig_ext sig) n a (nth i (sig_ext sig) (vec … c) (blank sig)) i) ?)
+            [%2 %1 // | whd in match (no_head ???); >nth_change_vec_neq [|@daemon]
+             >Hhead whd in ⊢ (??%?→?); #H1 destruct (H1)]] 
+         #Hls1_nil >Hls1_nil in H1; whd in ⊢ (???%→?); #H destruct (H)
+         >reverse_single #Htout
+         %{ls2} %{(change_vec (sig_ext sig) n a (nth i (sig_ext sig) (vec … c) (blank sig)) i)} 
+         %{(c::rs1)}
+         %[%[%[%[%[@Htout|//]|//]|//] |(*absurd*)@daemon] 
+          |>to_blank_cons_b
+             [>(to_blank_cons_b … Hblank) //| >nth_change_vec [@Hblank |@daemon]] 
+          ]
+        |(* we do not find the head: this is absurd *)
+         * #b * #lss * * #HF @False_ind
+         lapply (HF … (shift_i sig n i a c) ?) [%2 %1 //] 
+         whd in match (no_head ???); >nth_change_vec_neq [|@daemon]
+         >Hhead whd in ⊢ (??%?→?); #H destruct (H)
+        ]
+      ]
+    |
+    
+  (* end of the first case !! *)
+       
+        
+    
+   #Ht2
+    
+
+
+