Camera ready.

[helm.git] / helm / papers / calculemus-2003 / referaggio_hbugs_short.txt

diff --git a/helm/papers/calculemus-2003/referaggio_hbugs_short.txt b/helm/papers/calculemus-2003/referaggio_hbugs_short.txt
index 3391bbf334ca0ab7d2431b9af235705d4fa0f07c..8cd16d934a8e3492458de021bf7350a963c05ee1 100644 (file)
--- a/helm/papers/calculemus-2003/referaggio_hbugs_short.txt
+++ b/helm/papers/calculemus-2003/referaggio_hbugs_short.txt
@@ -1,30 +1,7 @@
-RILEGGERE E CORREGGERE:
-
-// certainly non-optimal presentation and structure. There are also quite many
-   typos
-/ English: lots of errors in the third-person conjugation of verbs (missing s),
-  please correct them - I will not list all of them. Try to have a native
-  English speaker read the paper.
-- Sessions 2 and 4 are too long, there are many repetitions.
-
-
 ROBA SOSTANZIALE:
 
-// The work presented in this paper, however, is still in a preliminary stage
-   and convincing, novel scientific aspects are hardly identifiable
-   (vedi sotto "Possibili spunti")
-
-Possibili spunti:
-
-NO:   H-Bugs is an improved realization of the O-Ants approach; the
-      architecture of H-Bugs is superior to that of O-Ants and H-Bugs
-      provides more or at least some improved functionalities.
 YES:  H-Bugs is simply an adaptation of a subset of the functionalities
       of O-Ants to the MONET web-services/brokers approach.
-HHMM: The paper presents a case study with H-Bugs that gives novel insights or
-NO    provides new evidence for the usefulness of systems like H-Bugs and
-      O-Ants. (Because the title says  ...: a case study  this is what the
-      reader first expects).
 
 (ii)  In the conclusion the authors admit that their work is rather
       preliminary and that a real integration into the
@@ -38,17 +15,15 @@ NO    provides new evidence for the usefulness of systems like H-Bugs and
       provided? I was actually hoping to find some more client independent
       modelings of tutor services. Since this seems to be not an issue it
       raises the question what the benefits of a modeling of H-Bugs within the
-      MONET web-services / brokers approach generally can be? Where is the
-      abstraction that is typically achieved in service/broker modelings (see
-      second paragraph in the Introduction)? If there is no abstraction
+      MONET web-services / brokers approach generally can be?
+      
+      Where is the abstraction that is typically achieved in service/broker
+      modelings (see second paragraph in the Introduction)?
+
+      If there is no abstraction
       achieved over the representation format for proofs used by HELM what
       again is the difference to O-Ants: the main application of O-Ants
       operates on the OMEGA proof datastructure; however it has been claimed
       that the O-Ants architecture is independent from it and this has
       recently been illustrated by applications of the system in other
       settings (e.g. paper at MKM-1001, Festschrift-Siekmann).
-(iii) A proper evaluation of the case study is missing and the authors
-      themselves mention proper assessment as future work. The claim that the
-      tutor embodying the HELM-Search-Engine has effectively increased the
-      productivity  of users is not at all justified in the paper.
-