helm/ocaml/tactics/discriminationTactics.ml

   1 (* Copyright (C) 2002, HELM Team.
   2  *
   3  * This file is part of HELM, an Hypertextual, Electronic
   4  * Library of Mathematics, developed at the Computer Science
   5  * Department, University of Bologna, Italy.
   6  *
   7  * HELM is free software; you can redistribute it and/or
   8  * modify it under the terms of the GNU General Public License
   9  * as published by the Free Software Foundation; either version 2
  10  * of the License, or (at your option) any later version.
  11  *
  12  * HELM is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
  13  * but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
  14  * MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the
  15  * GNU General Public License for more details.
  16  *
  17  * You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License
  18  * along with HELM; if not, write to the Free Software
  19  * Foundation, Inc., 59 Temple Place - Suite 330, Boston,
  20  * MA  02111-1307, USA.
  21  *
  22  * For details, see the HELM World-Wide-Web page,
  23  * http://cs.unibo.it/helm/.
  24  *)
  25
  26 let debug_print = fun _ -> ()
  27
  28 let rec injection_tac ~term =
  29  let injection_tac ~term status =
  30   let (proof, goal) = status in
  31   let module C = Cic in
  32   let module U = UriManager in
  33   let module P = PrimitiveTactics in
  34   let module T = Tacticals in
  35   let _,metasenv,_,_ = proof in
  36   let _,context,_ = CicUtil.lookup_meta goal metasenv in
  37   let termty,_ = (* TASSI: FIXME *)
  38     CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv context term CicUniv.empty_ugraph in
  39     ProofEngineTypes.apply_tactic
  40       (match termty with
  41           (C.Appl [(C.MutInd (equri, 0, [])) ; tty ; t1 ; t2])
  42              when (U.eq equri HelmLibraryObjects.Logic.eq_URI) -> (
  43            match tty with
  44               (C.MutInd (turi,typeno,exp_named_subst))
  45             | (C.Appl (C.MutInd (turi,typeno,exp_named_subst)::_)) -> (
  46                    match t1,t2 with
  47                       ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1)),
  48                        (C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2)))
  49                          when (uri1 = uri2) && (typeno1 = typeno2) &&
  50                               (consno1 = consno2) && (exp_named_subst1 = exp_named_subst2) ->
  51                        (* raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Injection: nothing to do") ; *) T.id_tac
  52                     | ((C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1))::applist1)),
  53                        (C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2))::applist2)))
  54                          when (uri1 = uri2) && (typeno1 = typeno2) && (consno1 = consno2) && (exp_named_subst1 = exp_named_subst2) ->
  55                        let rec traverse_list i l1 l2 =
  56                          match l1,l2 with
  57                             [],[] -> T.id_tac
  58                           | hd1::tl1,hd2::tl2 ->
  59                              T.then_
  60                               ~start:(injection1_tac ~i ~term)
  61                               ~continuation:(traverse_list (i+1) tl1 tl2)
  62                           | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: i 2 termini hanno in testa lo stesso costruttore, ma applicato a un numero diverso di termini. possibile???") ; T.id_tac
  63                        in traverse_list 1 applist1 applist2
  64                     | ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1)),
  65                        (C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2)))
  66                     | ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1)),
  67                        (C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2))::_)))
  68                     | ((C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1))::_)),
  69                        (C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2)))
  70                     | ((C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1))::_)),
  71                        (C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2))::_)))
  72                          when (consno1 <> consno2) || (exp_named_subst1 <> exp_named_subst2) ->
  73                        (* raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Injection: not a projectable equality but a discriminable one") ; *) T.id_tac
  74                     | _ -> (* raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Injection: not a projectable equality") ; *) T.id_tac
  75                    )
  76             | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Injection: not a projectable equality")
  77            )
  78         | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Injection: not an equation")
  79       ) status
  80  in
  81   ProofEngineTypes.mk_tactic (injection_tac ~term)
  82
  83 and injection1_tac ~term ~i =
  84  let injection1_tac ~term ~i status =
  85   let (proof, goal) = status in
  86   (* precondizione: t1 e t2 hanno in testa lo stesso costruttore ma differiscono (o potrebbero differire?) nell'i-esimo parametro del costruttore *)
  87    let module C = Cic in
  88    let module S = CicSubstitution in
  89    let module U = UriManager in
  90    let module P = PrimitiveTactics in
  91    let module T = Tacticals in
  92    let _,metasenv,_,_ = proof in
  93    let _,context,_ = CicUtil.lookup_meta goal metasenv in
  94    let termty,_ = (* TASSI: FIXME *)
  95      CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv context term CicUniv.empty_ugraph in
  96      match termty with (* an equality *)
  97          (C.Appl [(C.MutInd (equri, 0, [])) ; tty ; t1 ; t2])
  98              when (U.eq equri HelmLibraryObjects.Logic.eq_URI) -> (
  99            match tty with (* some inductive type *)
 100               (C.MutInd (turi,typeno,exp_named_subst))
 101             | (C.Appl (C.MutInd (turi,typeno,exp_named_subst)::_)) ->
 102                let t1',t2',consno = (* sono i due sottotermini che differiscono *)
 103                 match t1,t2 with
 104                    ((C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1))::applist1)),
 105                     (C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2))::applist2)))
 106                       when (uri1 = uri2) && (typeno1 = typeno2) && (consno1 = consno2) && (exp_named_subst1 = exp_named_subst2) -> (* controllo ridondante *)
 107                     (List.nth applist1 (i-1)),(List.nth applist2 (i-1)),consno2
 108                  | _ -> assert false
 109                in
 110                 let tty',_ =
 111                   CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv context t1'
 112                     CicUniv.empty_ugraph  in
 113                 let pattern =
 114                       match fst(CicEnvironment.get_obj
 115                                   CicUniv.empty_ugraph turi ) with
 116                          C.InductiveDefinition (ind_type_list,_,nr_ind_params_dx,_)  ->
 117                           let _,_,_,constructor_list = (List.nth ind_type_list typeno) in
 118                            let i_constr_id,_ = List.nth constructor_list (consno - 1) in
 119                             List.map
 120                              (function (id,cty) ->
 121                                let reduced_cty = CicReduction.whd context cty in
 122                                 let rec aux t k =
 123                                  match t with
 124                                     C.Prod (_,_,target) when (k <= nr_ind_params_dx) ->
 125                                      aux target (k+1)
 126                                   | C.Prod (binder,source,target) when (k > nr_ind_params_dx) ->
 127                                     let binder' =
 128                                       match binder with
 129                                          C.Name b -> C.Name b
 130                                        | C.Anonymous -> C.Name "y"
 131                                      in
 132                                       C.Lambda (binder',source,(aux target (k+1)))
 133                                   | _ ->
 134                                      let nr_param_constr = k - 1 - nr_ind_params_dx in
 135                                       if (id = i_constr_id)
 136                                        then C.Rel (nr_param_constr - i + 1)
 137                                        else S.lift (nr_param_constr + 1) t1' (* + 1 per liftare anche il lambda agguinto esternamente al case *)
 138                                 in aux reduced_cty 1
 139                              )
 140                              constructor_list
 141                        | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: object is not an Inductive Definition: it's imposible")
 142                 in
 143                 ProofEngineTypes.apply_tactic
 144                  (T.thens
 145                   ~start:(P.cut_tac (C.Appl [(C.MutInd (equri,0,[])) ; tty' ; t1' ; t2']))
 146                   ~continuations:[
 147                     T.then_
 148                      ~start:(injection_tac ~term:(C.Rel 1))
 149                      ~continuation:T.id_tac (* !!! qui devo anche fare clear di term tranne al primo passaggio *)
 150                     ;
 151                     T.then_
 152                      ~start:(ProofEngineTypes.mk_tactic
 153                        (fun status ->
 154                          let (proof, goal) = status in
 155                          let _,metasenv,_,_ = proof in
 156                           let _,context,gty = CicUtil.lookup_meta goal metasenv in
 157                            let new_t1' =
 158                             match gty with
 159                                (C.Appl (C.MutInd (_,_,_)::arglist)) ->
 160                                 List.nth arglist 1
 161                              | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Injection: goal after cut is not correct")
 162                            in
 163                             ProofEngineTypes.apply_tactic
 164                             (ReductionTactics.change_tac
 165                                ~pattern:(ProofEngineTypes.conclusion_pattern (Some new_t1'))
 166                                (C.Appl [
 167                                  C.Lambda (
 168                                   C.Name "x", tty,
 169                                   C.MutCase (
 170                                    turi, typeno,
 171                                    (C.Lambda (
 172                                     (C.Name "x"),
 173                                     (S.lift 1 tty),
 174                                     (S.lift 2 tty'))),
 175                                    (C.Rel 1), pattern
 176                                   )
 177                                  );
 178                                  t1]
 179                                ))
 180                         status
 181                        ))
 182                      ~continuation:
 183                        (T.then_
 184                          ~start:
 185                            (EqualityTactics.rewrite_simpl_tac
 186                              ~direction:`LeftToRight
 187                              ~pattern:(ProofEngineTypes.conclusion_pattern None)
 188                              term)
 189                          ~continuation:EqualityTactics.reflexivity_tac
 190                        )
 191                    ])
 192                   status
 193             | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: not a discriminable equality")
 194            )
 195         | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: not an equality")
 196  in
 197   ProofEngineTypes.mk_tactic (injection1_tac ~term ~i)
 198 ;;
 199
 200
 201
 202 exception TwoDifferentSubtermsFound of int
 203
 204 (* term ha tipo t1=t2; funziona solo se t1 e t2 hanno in testa costruttori
 205 diversi *)
 206
 207 let discriminate'_tac ~term =
 208  let discriminate'_tac ~term status =
 209   let (proof, goal) = status in
 210   let module C = Cic in
 211   let module U = UriManager in
 212   let module P = PrimitiveTactics in
 213   let module T = Tacticals in
 214   let _,metasenv,_,_ = proof in
 215   let _,context,_ = CicUtil.lookup_meta goal metasenv in
 216   let termty,_ =
 217     CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv context term CicUniv.empty_ugraph in
 218       match termty with
 219          (C.Appl [(C.MutInd (equri, 0, [])) ; tty ; t1 ; t2])
 220           when (U.eq equri HelmLibraryObjects.Logic.eq_URI) -> (
 221            match tty with
 222               (C.MutInd (turi,typeno,exp_named_subst))
 223             | (C.Appl (C.MutInd (turi,typeno,exp_named_subst)::_)) ->
 224
 225                 let consno2 = (* bruuutto: uso un eccezione per terminare con successo! buuu!! :-/ *)
 226                  try
 227                   let rec traverse t1 t2 =
 228                    match t1,t2 with
 229                       ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1)),
 230                        (C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2)))
 231                          when (uri1 = uri2) && (typeno1 = typeno2) && (consno1 = consno2) && (exp_named_subst1 = exp_named_subst2) ->
 232                        0
 233                     | ((C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1))::applist1)),
 234                        (C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2))::applist2)))
 235                          when (uri1 = uri2) && (typeno1 = typeno2) && (consno1 = consno2) && (exp_named_subst1 = exp_named_subst2) ->
 236                        let rec traverse_list l1 l2 =
 237                          match l1,l2 with
 238                             [],[] -> 0
 239                           | hd1::tl1,hd2::tl2 -> traverse hd1 hd2; traverse_list tl1 tl2
 240                           | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: i 2 termini hanno in testa lo stesso costruttore, ma applicato a un numero diverso di termini. possibile???")
 241                        in traverse_list applist1 applist2
 242
 243                     | ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1)),
 244                        (C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2)))
 245                     | ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1)),
 246                        (C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2))::_)))
 247                     | ((C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1))::_)),
 248                        (C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2)))
 249                     | ((C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1))::_)),
 250                        (C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2))::_)))
 251                          when (consno1 <> consno2) || (exp_named_subst1 <> exp_named_subst2) ->
 252                        raise (TwoDifferentSubtermsFound consno2)
 253                     | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: not a discriminable equality")
 254                   in traverse t1 t2
 255                  with (TwoDifferentSubtermsFound consno2) -> consno2
 256                 in
 257                  if consno2 = 0
 258                   then raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: Discriminating terms are structurally equal")
 259                   else
 260
 261                    let pattern =
 262                      (* a list of "True" except for the element in position consno2 which is "False" *)
 263                      match fst(CicEnvironment.get_obj
 264                                  CicUniv.empty_ugraph turi) with
 265                         C.InductiveDefinition (ind_type_list,_,nr_ind_params,_)  ->
 266                          let _,_,_,constructor_list = (List.nth ind_type_list typeno) in
 267                           let false_constr_id,_ = List.nth constructor_list (consno2 - 1) in
 268                            List.map
 269                             (function (id,cty) ->
 270                               let red_ty = CicReduction.whd context cty in (* dubbio: e' corretto ridurre in questo context ??? *)
 271                                let rec aux t k =
 272                                 match t with
 273                                    C.Prod (_,_,target) when (k <= nr_ind_params) ->
 274                                     aux target (k+1)
 275                                  | C.Prod (binder,source,target) when (k > nr_ind_params) ->
 276                                     C.Lambda (binder,source,(aux target (k+1)))
 277                                  | _ ->
 278                                     if (id = false_constr_id)
 279                                      then (C.MutInd(HelmLibraryObjects.Logic.false_URI,0,[]))
 280                                      else (C.MutInd(HelmLibraryObjects.Logic.true_URI,0,[]))
 281                                in aux red_ty 1
 282                             )
 283                             constructor_list
 284                       | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: object is not an Inductive Definition: it's imposible")
 285                    in
 286
 287                     let (proof',goals') =
 288                      ProofEngineTypes.apply_tactic
 289                       (EliminationTactics.elim_type_tac
 290                        ~term:(C.MutInd(HelmLibraryObjects.Logic.false_URI,0,[])))
 291                       status
 292                     in
 293                      (match goals' with
 294                          [goal'] ->
 295                           let _,metasenv',_,_ = proof' in
 296                            let _,context',gty' =
 297                              CicUtil.lookup_meta goal' metasenv'
 298                            in
 299                             ProofEngineTypes.apply_tactic
 300                             (T.then_
 301                              ~start:
 302                               (ReductionTactics.change_tac
 303                                ~pattern:(ProofEngineTypes.conclusion_pattern (Some gty'))
 304                                (C.Appl [
 305                                  C.Lambda (
 306                                   C.Name "x", tty,
 307                                   C.MutCase (
 308                                    turi, typeno,
 309                                    (C.Lambda ((C.Name "x"),tty,(C.Sort C.Prop))),
 310                                    (C.Rel 1), pattern
 311                                   )
 312                                  );
 313                                  t2]
 314                                )
 315                               )
 316                              ~continuation:
 317                               (
 318                                  T.then_
 319                                    ~start:
 320                                      (EqualityTactics.rewrite_simpl_tac
 321                                        ~direction:`RightToLeft
 322                                        ~pattern:(ProofEngineTypes.conclusion_pattern None)
 323                                        term)
 324                                    ~continuation:(IntroductionTactics.constructor_tac ~n:1)
 325                               ))
 326                              (proof',goal')
 327                        | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: ElimType False left more (or less) than one goal")
 328                      )
 329             | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: not a discriminable equality")
 330            )
 331        | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: not an equality")
 332  in
 333   ProofEngineTypes.mk_tactic (discriminate'_tac ~term)
 334 ;;
 335
 336 let discriminate_tac ~term =
 337  let discriminate_tac ~term status =
 338   ProofEngineTypes.apply_tactic
 339   (Tacticals.then_
 340     ~start:(* (injection_tac ~term) *) Tacticals.id_tac
 341     ~continuation:(discriminate'_tac ~term)) (* NOOO!!! non term ma una (qualunque) delle nuove hyp introdotte da inject *)
 342    status
 343  in
 344   ProofEngineTypes.mk_tactic (discriminate_tac ~term)
 345 ;;
 346
 347
 348
 349 let decide_equality_tac =
 350 (* il goal e' un termine della forma t1=t2\/~t1=t2; la tattica decide se l'uguaglianza
 351 e' vera o no e lo risolve *)
 352   Tacticals.id_tac
 353 ;;
 354
 355
 356
 357 let compare_tac ~term = Tacticals.id_tac
 358  (*
 359 (* term is in the form t1=t2; the tactic leaves two goals: in the first you have to          *)
 360 (* demonstrate the goal with the additional hyp that t1=t2, in the second the hyp is ~t1=t2  *)
 361   let module C = Cic in
 362   let module U = UriManager in
 363   let module P = PrimitiveTactics in
 364   let module T = Tacticals in
 365    let _,metasenv,_,_ = proof in
 366     let _,context,gty = CicUtil.lookup_meta goal metasenv in
 367      let termty = (CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv context term) in
 368       match termty with
 369          (C.Appl [(C.MutInd (uri, 0, [])); _; t1; t2]) when (uri = (U.uri_of_string "cic:/Coq/Init/Logic/eq.ind")) ->
 370
 371           let term' = (* (t1=t2)\/~(t1=t2) *)
 372            C.Appl [
 373             (C.MutInd ((U.uri_of_string "cic:/Coq/Init/Logic/or.ind"), 0, [])) ;
 374             term ;
 375             C.Appl [
 376              (C.MutInd ((U.uri_of_string "cic:/Coq/Init/Logic/eq.ind"), 1, [])) ;
 377              t1 ;
 378              C.Appl [C.Const ((U.uri_of_string "cic:/Coq/Init/Logic/not.con"), []) ; t2]
 379             ]
 380            ]
 381           in
 382             T.thens
 383                ~start:(P.cut_tac ~term:term')
 384                ~continuations:[
 385                  T.then_ ~start:(P.intros_tac) ~continuation:(P.elim_intros_simpl_tac ~term:(C.Rel 1)) ;
 386                  decide_equality_tac]
 387                status
 388       | (C.Appl [(C.MutInd (uri, 0, [])); _; t1; t2]) when (uri = (U.uri_of_string "cic:/Coq/Init/Logic_Type/eqT.ind")) ->
 389           let term' = (* (t1=t2) \/ ~(t1=t2) *)
 390            C.Appl [
 391             (C.MutInd ((U.uri_of_string "cic:/Coq/Init/Logic/or.ind"), 0, [])) ;
 392             term ;
 393             C.Appl [
 394              (C.MutInd ((U.uri_of_string "cic:/Coq/Init/Logic_Type/eqT.ind"), 1, [])) ;
 395              t1 ;
 396              C.Appl [C.Const ((U.uri_of_string "cic:/Coq/Init/Logic/not.con"), []) ; t2]
 397             ]
 398            ]
 399           in
 400             T.thens
 401                ~start:(P.cut_tac ~term:term')
 402                ~continuations:[
 403                  T.then_ ~start:(P.intros_tac) ~continuation:(P.elim_intros_simpl_tac ~term:(C.Rel 1)) ;
 404                  decide_equality_tac]
 405                status
 406       | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Compare: Not an equality")
 407 *)
 408 ;;
 409
 410
 411
 412 (* DISCRIMINTATE SENZA INJECTION
 413
 414 exception TwoDifferentSubtermsFound of (Cic.term * Cic.term * int)
 415
 416 let discriminate_tac ~term status =
 417   let module C = Cic in
 418   let module U = UriManager in
 419   let module P = PrimitiveTactics in
 420   let module T = Tacticals in
 421   let (proof, goal) = status in
 422    let _,metasenv,_,_ = proof in
 423     let _,context,_ = CicUtil.lookup_meta goal metasenv in
 424      let termty = (CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv context term) in
 425       match termty with
 426          (C.Appl [(C.MutInd (equri, 0, [])) ; tty ; t1 ; t2])
 427           when (U.eq equri (U.uri_of_string "cic:/Coq/Init/Logic/eq.ind"))
 428             or (U.eq equri (U.uri_of_string "cic:/Coq/Init/Logic_Type/eqT.ind")) -> (
 429            match tty with
 430               (C.MutInd (turi,typeno,exp_named_subst))
 431             | (C.Appl (C.MutInd (turi,typeno,exp_named_subst)::_)) ->
 432
 433                 let (t1',t2',consno2') = (* bruuutto: uso un eccezione per terminare con successo! buuu!! :-/ *)
 434                  try
 435                   let rec traverse t1 t2 =
 436 debug_print ("XXXX t1 " ^ CicPp.ppterm t1) ;
 437 debug_print ("XXXX t2 " ^ CicPp.ppterm t2) ;
 438                    match t1,t2 with
 439                       ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1)),
 440                        (C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2)))
 441                          when (uri1 = uri2) && (typeno1 = typeno2) && (consno1 = consno2) && (exp_named_subst1 = exp_named_subst2) ->
 442                        t1,t2,0
 443                     | ((C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1))::applist1)),
 444                        (C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2))::applist2)))
 445                          when (uri1 = uri2) && (typeno1 = typeno2) && (consno1 = consno2) && (exp_named_subst1 = exp_named_subst2) ->
 446                        let rec traverse_list l1 l2 =
 447                          match l1,l2 with
 448                             [],[] -> t1,t2,0
 449                           | hd1::tl1,hd2::tl2 -> traverse hd1 hd2; traverse_list tl1 tl2
 450                           | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: i 2 termini hanno in testa lo stesso costruttore, ma applicato a un numero diverso di termini. possibile???")
 451                        in traverse_list applist1 applist2
 452
 453                     | ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1)),
 454                        (C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2)))
 455                     | ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1)),
 456                        (C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2))::_)))
 457                     | ((C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1))::_)),
 458                        (C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2)))
 459                     | ((C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri1,typeno1,consno1,exp_named_subst1))::_)),
 460                        (C.Appl ((C.MutConstruct (uri2,typeno2,consno2,exp_named_subst2))::_)))
 461                          when (consno1 <> consno2) || (exp_named_subst1 <> exp_named_subst2) ->
 462                        raise (TwoDifferentSubtermsFound (t1,t2,consno2))
 463                     | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: not a discriminable equality")
 464                   in traverse t1 t2
 465                  with (TwoDifferentSubtermsFound (t1,t2,consno2)) -> (t1,t2,consno2)
 466                 in
 467 debug_print ("XXXX consno2' " ^ (string_of_int consno2')) ;
 468                  if consno2' = 0
 469                   then raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: Discriminating terms are structurally equal")
 470                   else
 471
 472                    let pattern =
 473                      (* a list of "True" except for the element in position consno2' which is "False" *)
 474                      match fst(CicEnvironment.get_obj turi
 475                                  CicUniv.empty_ugraph) with
 476                         C.InductiveDefinition (ind_type_list,_,nr_ind_params)  ->
 477 debug_print ("XXXX nth " ^ (string_of_int (List.length ind_type_list)) ^ " " ^ (string_of_int typeno)) ;
 478                          let _,_,_,constructor_list = (List.nth ind_type_list typeno) in
 479 debug_print ("XXXX nth " ^ (string_of_int (List.length constructor_list)) ^ " " ^ (string_of_int consno2')) ;
 480                           let false_constr_id,_ = List.nth constructor_list (consno2' - 1) in
 481 debug_print ("XXXX nth funzionano ") ;
 482                            List.map
 483                             (function (id,cty) ->
 484                               let red_ty = CicReduction.whd context cty in (* dubbio: e' corretto ridurre in questo context ??? *)
 485                                let rec aux t k =
 486                                 match t with
 487                                    C.Prod (_,_,target) when (k <= nr_ind_params) ->
 488                                     aux target (k+1)
 489                                  | C.Prod (binder,source,target) when (k > nr_ind_params) ->
 490                                     C.Lambda (binder,source,(aux target (k+1)))
 491                                  | _ ->
 492                                     if (id = false_constr_id)
 493                                      then (C.MutInd (U.uri_of_string "cic:/Coq/Init/Logic/False.ind") 0 [])
 494                                      else (C.MutInd (U.uri_of_string "cic:/Coq/Init/Logic/True.ind") 0 [])
 495                                in aux red_ty 1
 496                             )
 497                             constructor_list
 498                       | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: object is not an Inductive Definition: it's imposible")
 499                    in
 500
 501                     let (proof',goals') =
 502                      EliminationTactics.elim_type_tac
 503                       ~term:(C.MutInd (U.uri_of_string "cic:/Coq/Init/Logic/False.ind") 0 [] )
 504                       status
 505                     in
 506                      (match goals' with
 507                          [goal'] ->
 508                           let _,metasenv',_,_ = proof' in
 509                            let _,context',gty' =
 510                              CicUtil.lookup_meta goal' metasenv'
 511                            in
 512                             T.then_
 513                              ~start:
 514                               (P.change_tac
 515                                ~what:gty'
 516                                ~with_what:
 517                                 (C.Appl [
 518                                   C.Lambda (
 519                                    C.Name "x", tty,
 520                                    C.MutCase (
 521                                     turi, typeno,
 522                                     (C.Lambda ((C.Name "x"),tty,(C.Sort C.Prop))),
 523                                     (C.Rel 1), pattern
 524                                    )
 525                                   );
 526                                   t2']
 527                                 )
 528                               )
 529                              ~continuation:
 530                               (
 531 debug_print ("XXXX rewrite<-: " ^ CicPp.ppterm (CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv' context' (C.Appl [(C.MutInd (equri,0,[])) ; tty ; t1' ; t2'])));
 532 debug_print ("XXXX rewrite<-: " ^ CicPp.ppterm (C.Appl [(C.MutInd (equri,0,[])) ; tty ; t1' ; t2'])) ;
 533 debug_print ("XXXX equri: " ^ U.string_of_uri equri) ;
 534 debug_print ("XXXX tty : " ^ CicPp.ppterm tty) ;
 535 debug_print ("XXXX tt1': " ^ CicPp.ppterm (CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv' context' t1')) ;
 536 debug_print ("XXXX tt2': " ^ CicPp.ppterm (CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv' context' t2')) ;
 537 if (CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv' context' t1') <> tty then debug_print ("XXXX tt1': " ^ CicPp.ppterm (CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv' context' t1')) ;
 538 if (CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv' context' t2') <> tty then debug_print ("XXXX tt2': " ^ CicPp.ppterm (CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv' context' t2')) ;
 539 if (CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv' context' t1') <> (CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv' context' t2')
 540  then debug_print ("XXXX tt1': " ^ CicPp.ppterm (CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux'
 541  metasenv' context' t1')) ; debug_print ("XXXX tt2': " ^ CicPp.ppterm (CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv' context' t2')) ;
 542
 543                                let termty' = ProofEngineReduction.replace_lifting ~equality:(==) ~what:t1 ~with_what:t1' ~where:termty in
 544                                 let termty'' = ProofEngineReduction.replace_lifting ~equality:(==) ~what:t2 ~with_what:t2' ~where:termty' in
 545
 546 debug_print ("XXXX rewrite<- " ^ CicPp.ppterm term ^ " : " ^ CicPp.ppterm (CicTypeChecker.type_of_aux' metasenv' context' term));
 547                                  T.then_
 548                                    ~start:(EqualityTactics.rewrite_back_simpl_tac ~term:term)
 549                                    ~continuation:(IntroductionTactics.constructor_tac ~n:1)
 550                               )
 551                              (proof',goal')
 552                        | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: ElimType False left more (or less) than one goal")
 553                      )
 554             | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: not a discriminable equality")
 555            )
 556        | _ -> raise (ProofEngineTypes.Fail "Discriminate: not an equality")
 557 ;;
 558
 559 *)
 560
 561
 562